Skip to main content
Premier resource for practicing structural engineers
Go back to https://www.structuremag.org/articles Back
Bridges

(Re)building Bridges

By Lili Boenigk
November 2, 2026

To view the figures and tables associated with this article, please refer to the flipbook above.

Grant County, Oklahoma, has built six steel girder bridges over the last six years—and hasn’t bought a single new beam.

Counties and municipalities are responsible for 75% of all highways and roads across the U.S., but many struggle to maintain their bridges on tight budgets. This is particularly true for rural counties in the Midwest with large road networks and many lightly-traveled, short-span bridges. In fact, more than half of all structurally deficient bridges in the U.S. are short-span structures owned by counties and municipalities.

To save on cost, many county engineers get creative with what they have. By reusing steel beams in short-span bridge replacements, counties can cut superstructure material costs by over half. Steel can be reused safely in low-traffic bridges with minimal refurbishment. At least 557 reused steel bridges are now across six U.S. states, including Ohio, Iowa, Oklahoma, South Dakota, New York, and Nebraska.

In these projects, cost savings and sustainability go hand in hand. Reusing steel directly avoids the energy-intensive re-melting required for recycling, along with the emissions associated with processing and transporting scrap. As a result, reused steel superstructures have, on average, 58% lower embodied carbon than their new steel counterparts.

The Challenge

Muskingum County has Ohio’s largest county-maintained road network and one of its smallest tax bases. Along with snow removal, resurfacing, and other routine work, the county maintains 407 bridges.

Many rural counties face the same challenge: budgets scale with population, but road and bridge obligations scale with land area. Short-span bridge replacements quickly absorb limited budgets, despite seeing minimal traffic. In Midwestern states laid out on a road grid, the same creek may be crossed several times within a given county.

Despite seeing limited traffic, these bridges are critical for local economies. Randy Robinson, who works with county road departments through Oklahoma’s Circuit Engineering Districts Board, describes a typical day’s load on one of these crossings as: “one school bus in the morning, one in the evening, some cars and trucks, and one overloaded piece of farm equipment.” There are often limited alternative routes. A bridge closure can add a half-hour detour, a burden that falls hardest on farmers hauling equipment and grain on tight schedules. Keeping critical short-span crossings open necessitates new, cost-effective engineering solutions.

Refurbishment and Cost

Cost, not sustainability, drives reuse in short-span bridges. In a survey of 71 practitioners and interviews with 29, 85% cited cost savings as their primary motivation, ahead of constructability and convenience (41%) and environmental considerations (14%).

The savings are large because most counties reuse steel with minimal refurbishment. Bridges are often replaced for reasons unrelated to the superstructure (road realignment, substructure failure) so salvaged beams are frequently in good condition. Even when beams are damaged, corrosion is typically concentrated at the ends of the girders, where steel interfaces with bearing pads and is exposed to water. Many counties simply cut off the damaged ends and reuse what remains. Some go further, sandblasting, repainting, or galvanizing. Careful deconstruction adds cost, particularly for composite concrete deck bridges, but not enough to offset what is saved on new steel.

Survey respondents report average savings of 24% of total project cost, reaching 80% in some cases. Documented reused-steel bridges in Ohio and Oklahoma came in 66% and 47% below FHWA national baselines per m², respectively. Whether the economics work out in a given case depends on what the salvaged steel costs and how much refurbishment it needs.

Counties with in-house fabrication and construction crews are best positioned to capture those savings. They avoid the lead times that come with ordering new steel, and with material already stockpiled, crews can start a replacement when it suits them. Mark Eicher credits his bridge crew with making Muskingum County’s program possible: “A lot of counties don’t have the expertise or the equipment or manpower to do the actual construction that we have. We were fortunate to have some guys that are very good at it.”

Steel Reuse in Practice

Warren Schlatter in Defiance County, Ohio, started by salvaging beams from in-county bridge replacements to replace individual damaged girders. Within a few years, he was building entire bridges from reused steel. Muskingum County has done the same, reusing steel in 15 bridges since 2015, drawing on beams from its own bridges and from state-owned structures.

The Ohio Department of Transportation now supports this work through its Salvaged Steel Program. The initiative started in 2017, when the County Engineers Association of Ohio asked ODOT to offer beams from state bridge replacements to counties rather than scrapping them. Muskingum County’s engineer Mark Eicher points out that the program is “...mostly just to help counties that are in dire need of materials.” Each time ODOT replaces a bridge, it makes any reusable beams available at no cost for locally funded county projects nearby and covers the cost of hauling them. Since 2017, the program has distributed 317 W- and WF-shape beams totaling 1,370 tons.

The Oklahoma DOT coordinates a similar program, which has enabled the construction of 197 reused-steel bridges across the state since 2012. The Crosstown Bridge Beam program was catalyzed by the state’s backlog of deficient county bridges and spearheaded by Governor Mary Fallin and Transportation Secretary Gary Ridley. It began with the replacement of the 2.4 km Crosstown I-40 bridge in Oklahoma City, which yielded more than 2,060 salvageable steel beams. Rather than scrap them, the state distributed the beams to 21 staging areas around Oklahoma, where counties could take them at no cost for local projects.

McClain County Commissioner Wilson Lyles was among the first to utilize salvaged Crosstown beams to replace a wooden bridge dating to 1940. He called the beams “a true gift to the counties.” Grant County has since built six bridges from the Crosstown stockpile.

Not every county waits for a state program. Some buy salvaged steel directly, sourcing it from their own bridge replacements or from contractors doing demolition work. Todd Kinney in Clinton County, Iowa, takes the latter approach: “We use pretty much any opportunity to buy bridge beams as we can.”

Kinney approaches contractors at DOT preconstruction meetings and buys beams from the demolition sites for 18–21 cents per pound—this is above scrap value, but well below the price of new steel. The arrangement gives Kinney access to affordable, high-quality beams while saving contractors the labor and cost of cutting up steel for recycling.

Design, Safety, and Sustainability

Counties typically assume salvaged steel’s yield strength based on the year of construction, which can be found from internal or DOT records. Just under half of surveyed engineers (43%) apply an additional factor of safety when designing with salvaged members. Some go further and send members out for coupon testing to confirm material properties directly.

Since steel’s yield strength remains relatively consistent over time, reused steel’s structural safety is largely determined by fatigue life. Most bridges on low-traffic county systems see limited cyclical loading, and county engineers generally do not treat fatigue as a governing concern. Reused bridges also tend to be heavily overdesigned: girders salvaged from larger highway bridges have depths far exceeding what a short span requires. Three case-study bridges in Muskingum County, Ohio, have shear utilization ratios as low as 4.4% and moment utilization as low as 33.3%. Excessive section depth can also limit hydraulic clearance in some short-span crossings.

This overdesign does not erase the carbon advantage. Embodied carbon can be estimated using coefficients derived from life cycle analysis, and the AISC environmental product declaration is the accepted benchmark for high-recycled-content structural steel. No equivalent declaration exists for reused steel, so the comparison has to be made against bottom-up estimates from academic literature. On that basis, reuse cuts embodied carbon by 58% on average and by as much as 82.6%, even against a structurally optimized new-steel design.

Future Potential and Enabling Conditions

Reused steel offers counties a more cost-effective and less carbon-intensive way to replace short-span bridges. Rather than treating a demolished bridge as waste, counties treat it as an inventory of future infrastructure, recirculating the material’s value within the public sector and stretching limited budgets further. Whether the steel comes from a county’s own replacements, from a DOT-led program, or from a contractor’s demolition site, reuse is a practical response to aging infrastructure and tightening budgets.

Steel reuse works for county engineering offices with access to a predictable supply of steel, storage space, and in-house crews for fabrication and construction. State DOT coordination programs can amplify reuse efforts. Ohio’s Salvaged Steel Program shows that routine state replacements can feed a steady stream of beams to counties, and Oklahoma’s Crosstown project shows that a single large replacement can supply material for years.

If Grant County can build six bridges without buying new steel, the question is no longer whether steel reuse is possible. It is how many more counties could do the same with the right institutional support. ■

About the Author

Lili Boenigk is a PhD student in the Building Technology program in the Department of Architecture at MIT. Her research focuses on scaling the reuse of structural components to reduce the cost and carbon intensity of construction, with particular focus on bridges and emerging secondary markets.

Resources for Reusing Steel

  1. For more on the carbon implications of reuse and supply and demand, see:
    Berglund-Brown, Juliana, and John Ochsendorf. 2025. “Reusing Heavy-Section Steel in Buildings: Carbon Reduction Potential and Material Availability.” Journal of Architectural Engineering 31 (2): 04025020. https://doi.org/10.1061/JAEIED.AEENG-1918.
  2. For comprehensive practitioner guidance on reuse in bridges, see Expedition Engineering’s report:
    Robin, Clotilde, Hazel Needham, and Janet Botha. 2025. Steel Reuse in Bridges. Expedition Engineering, ICE. https://expedition.uk.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/04/Steel-Reuse-in-Bridges-Report_v2.pdf.
  3. For case studies on reuse of structural components, including steel, see:
    SE2050. n.d. SEI Circular Economy Case Studies. Accessed September 30, 2026. https://se2050.org/resources-overview/case-studies/sei-circular-economy-case-studies/.
  4. For more on Ohio’s Salvaged Steel Program, see:
    Ohio LTAP Center, dir. 2021. Bridge Upcycling in Ohio. 04:32. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r5AyX5uDH8U.
  5. For more on Oklahoma’s Crosstown Bridge Beam Program, see:
    Oklahoma Cooperative Circuit Engineering Districts Board. n.d. “Cross Town Bridge Beam Program.” Accessed September 30, 2026. https://www.occedb.org/cross-town-beams.html.
  6. Stay tuned for AISC’s soon-to-be released guidance document "Sustainable Steel: A comprehensive guide for project teams" with a chapter dedicated to steel reuse.